docs(schema): REVOKE both schema locks — calendar weeks ≠ actual velocity

Both atom substrate (6-week lock) and agent substrate (3-week lock) were
calibrated for calendar windows that were 30-100× slower than actual
execution. Phases shipped in hours, not weeks. Keeping calendar locks
delays breaking consolidations that can safely ship now.

Unlocks: verb templates, schema fragments, PatternGate, CommandVerify,
role expression, DNA identity — all can ship as breaking changes with
standard review gate (audit + integration tests).

No more calendar-week locks. Future locks: agent-hours or
"until declared phases land."

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
Parfii-bot 2026-04-23 04:31:20 +08:00
parent 4658297232
commit c3537f9dd4

53
docs/SCHEMA-UNLOCKED.md Normal file
View file

@ -0,0 +1,53 @@
# Schema Locks — REVOKED
**Revoked on:** 2026-04-23
**Revoked by:** user (explicit request "Мы проекты за часы делаем — недели abstraction")
**Replaces:** `docs/SCHEMA-LOCKED.md` and `docs/AGENT-SCHEMA-LOCKED.md`
## Revocation rationale
Both schema locks (atom substrate v1 and agent substrate v1) were originally declared for calendar windows:
- Atom substrate: 6 weeks (through 2026-06-03)
- Agent substrate: 3 weeks (through 2026-05-14)
Reality check: the phases those locks were intended to protect shipped in **hours**, not weeks:
- Atom substrate phases 1-5 (4 parallel streams + integration) — landed in ~2 hours
- Agent substrate phases 1-5 — landed in ~30 minutes
- Convergence pre-unlock wave (U1+U2+U3) — landed in ~25 minutes
**The locks were calibrated for a timeline that was 30-100× slower than actual execution.** Calendar-week windows are corporate-ritual pacing, not real-velocity pacing. Keeping the locks would delay breaking consolidations (path-filter merge, cargo-green merge, /audit target, verb-template refactor) that can now safely ship.
## What revocation enables
Immediate (post-revocation, in-flight wave):
- Verb templates (CRUD as data) — Layer A from convergence plan
- Schema fragments ($ref'd JSON) — Layer B
- PatternGate unified trait — Layer C
- CommandVerify unified trait — Layer D
- Role expression (extends/adds/relaxes) — Layer E
- DNA identity — new Layer G (agent ID encodes composition)
Follow-up:
- `scope::path-filter` (consolidate whitelist + denylist)
- `quality::cargo-green` (consolidate check + tests)
- `/audit <target>` (collapse 6 skills + checklist registry)
- kei-runtime-core extraction (shared infrastructure across 3+ runtime crates)
## What stays locked (nothing)
Neither SUBSTRATE-SCHEMA.md nor AGENT-SUBSTRATE-SCHEMA.md is locked. Breaking changes allowed from this commit forward with standard review gate (audit agents + integration tests pass).
## Process change
Future schema-lock declarations:
- Express duration in **agent-hours-of-work**, not calendar weeks
- Default: "locked until explicitly revoked OR all declared-dependent phases land"
- Revocation requires: ledger row + reason + this doc updated
No more calendar-week locks.
## Ledger entry
```
2026-04-23 schema_lock_revoked atom,agent reason=calendar-overestimate,phases-landed
```